11.4 Autotrophic biomass as an indicator of eutrophication11 Eutrophication and dose-response relationships in European
coastal waters11.2 Comparative analysis of dose-response relationships11.3 Different N:P loadings, dose-response relationships and points of no return

11.3 Different N:P loadings, dose-response relationships and points of no return

Changing N:P loading ratios may affect the biomass yield for a given input. For instance, the maximum autotrophic biomass yield for a given nutrient inputs was obtained at a N:P ratio of approximately 40, without any further increase in biomass yield at higher loading N:P ratios (Figure 5). Nutrients inputs vary between different regions across Europe. For example, there are significant differences between phosphorus and nitrogen loading in the Atlantic and the Mediterranean (Figure 6). These differences in loading N:P ratios result from differences in nutrient sources. In the Atlantic, the main nutrient sources are agriculture, industry and the atmosphere. However, in the Mediterranean they are mainly agriculture and domestic effluents (Duarte and Vidal, unpubl. data). In regional seas and enclosed recipients the variability in loading N:P ratios can even be higher.

carFig5

Figure: The relationship between the mean chlorophyll yield and the loading N/P ratio derived from a mesocosm experiment (MESOMED98) conducted in a Mediterranean coastal ecosystem (Duarte et al., unpubl. results).

 

Hence, there are indications, derived both from coordinated mesocosm experiments as well as from comparative analyses, that there are (i) major regional differences in nutrient inputs -- both quantity and quality -- and (ii) eutrophication dose-response patterns.

carFig6

Figure: The average (±SD) N and P loading to coastal waters in Mediterranean vs. Atlantic coastal waters [].

 

These would, in turn, yield important regional differences in the critical nutrient thresholds that have to be reflected by legislature. There is thus no generic nutrient input -- phytoplankton dose-response relationship in European coastal waters. Adequate information regarding these relationships does only exist for a selected number of regions.


11.4 Autotrophic biomass as an indicator of eutrophication11 Eutrophication and dose-response relationships in European
coastal waters11.2 Comparative analysis of dose-response relationships11.3 Different N:P loadings, dose-response relationships and points of no return