17.3 Phases17 Cultural eutrophication: perspectives and prospects17.1 History17.2 Cultural eutrophication

17.2 Cultural eutrophication: regions, ecosystems, changes and organisms

An important concept for cultural eutrophication is the residence time of nutrients in the recipient. Low water exchange results in high residence times and that increases the effect of the supplied nutrients and vice versa. The volume of the recipient influences its flushing time that determines the nutrient residence time (Figure 3). In addition the supply rate by discharge from the drainage basin influences the degree of eutrophication. In concert these factor can give rise to a large range of eutrophication scenarios, both on an annual and seasonal scale. High residence times will be encountered in land locked ecosystems such as fjords with high sills, the Baltic Sea and the Black Sea, while shallow regions or enclosed regions with lower threshold such as the northern Adriatic, the North Sea, Kattegat and many Norwegian fjords take an intermediate position. The degree of eutrophication is determined by the supply rate of nutrients. If the supply is high, such as the Kattegat, Baltic Sea, southern North Sea and certain estuaries and fjords, the combination of highs supply and increased residence times create a scenario for extensive cultural eutrophication.

cultFig3

Figure: Coastal systems can be classified according to their dilution and mixing capabilities. Here 138 coastal systems of the U.S. are classified according to dilution (volume of estuarine water above the pycnocline) and flushing (based on time to replace estuarine volume by freshwater inflow or tidal prism volume). Coastal systems falling in the lower left region of the graph are those with extreme large dilution volumes and short flashing times. One can expect these systems to be at least susceptible to eutrophication. Systems in the upper right region of the graph have the smallest dilution volumes and longest flushing times. One can expect these systems to be susceptible to eutrophication. From Anonymous [].

 

If the organic matter supply is greater than the degradation and oxygen reserves or its hydrodynamic supply seasonal or long-term hypoxia or anoxia will develop. This phenomenon has been encountered in increasing frequency and has been often been interpreted as a sign of eutrophication although changes in vertical mixing and stratification also can cause hypoxia or anoxia. Further, an increasing Harmful algae bloom (HAB) frequency have been interpreted as a consequence of eutrophication (Figure 4). In the Seto Inland Sea, one of the most important aquaculture regions in Japan, a large-scale increase in HABs was encountered from the 60ties and onwards. Increasing control of the effluents in the region in the 80ties and onwards ahs result in a sharp decrease in HAB. However, it is not easy to indicate with confidence if the increased frequency of HAB all over the world is accelerated by eutrophication. For this we have too few reports from the days prior to aquaculture and to few long time series of phytoplankton. HAB have been observed throughout the times: The first HAB report can be found in the Old Testament (Exodus 7: 20-21). "...and all the waters that were in the river were turned to blood. And the fish that was in the river died; and the river stank, and the Egyptians could not drink the water of the river ...". On the background of the extensive changes in ecosystem structure and composition increased HAB frequencies seem most likely.

cultFig4

Figure: Expansion of harmful algae bloom (HAB) problems in the U.S.. These maps depict the HAB outbreaks known before and after 1972. This maps are rather indications of outbreaks than exhaustive compilations of all events. Remark the increasing frequency of HAB events along the coast with the highest population densities. There has been no increase in HAB event frequencies in low-populated regions such as Alaska and Hawaii. NSP = Neurotic shellfish poisoning; PSP = Paralytic shellfish poisoning; ASP = Amnesic shellfish poisoning. From Anderson [] and Anonymous [].

 

Advent of opportunists and introduced species in eutrophicated regions is well known. For example, 3/4 of the benthic biomass of the Rhine River is comprised by inadvertently introduced species. There is great concern worldwide what happens to lacustrin and marine ecosystems under the impact of introduced and alien species. The number of alien species, often introduced by ballast waters, transport of aquaculture organisms, channels or voluntary introduction, is ever increasing. The long-term consequences are more or less unknown.


17.3 Phases17 Cultural eutrophication: perspectives and prospects17.1 History17.2 Cultural eutrophication